Advice on a HUGE fantasy baseball trade?!?

No I woudldn't. Fielder is having an All-Star year obviously, Buehrle and Beckett are having very solid year's pitching. You are getting the number one fantasy pitcher , and a good pitcher in Jurrjens, but the two hitters you're getting don't add up to the numbers you'll get with Fielder. Atkins is terrible this year and I wouldn't even want him on my team. I think I'd decline the trade.